The modern marketing landscape is being rewritten in near real time. While economic uncertainty may tempt brands to retreat into the comfort of walled gardens, the truth is more nuanced, especially regarding data and identity solutions.
Marketers today have more options than ever, with the growing adoption of modular or composable data stacks opening new possibilities for flexibility and innovation.
But with greater choice comes greater complexity.
As brands navigate a fragmented ecosystem of signals, platforms and privacy constraints, identity has reemerged as a strategic linchpin.
Choosing the right foundational identity partner isn’t just a box to check; it’s a critical decision that determines how well your entire stack performs, scales and adapts to change.
Here’s how to make that call with confidence.
- Can you build on the foundation?
A strong identity solution starts with a durable foundation, one that merges persistent offline data with dynamic digital signals to create a unified, privacy-safe identity graph. This graph should span individuals, households and devices, while functioning seamlessly across platforms and environments.
Keep in mind that this “spine” doesn’t have to come from a single vendor, but it must be accurate, scalable and future-proof. One size does not fit all. The goal is a flexible base that adapts as your use cases evolve.
- Understand match rates and what they actually mean
Impressive match rates are only meaningful if built on sound methodology that directly supports your goals and desired outcomes. Be wary of inflated metrics that look better than they may actually be and rely on vague definitions or the blending of deterministic and probabilistic matches.
The best partners will offer transparency through confidence scores, lookback windows and clear match logic that give you genuine control over precision and scale.
- Prioritize data accuracy and integrity
Not all data is created equal.
Choose identity partners who start with clean, ethically sourced, up-to-date and well-governed data. Those who build for real-world use cases – like direct mail – tend to apply higher standards for hygiene and governance, resulting in less identity drift and greater accuracy when layering in algorithmic scale.
- Can you access and activate the data?
Cloud-native organizations demand agility.
Your identity partner should support flexible data access, allowing you to build, test and derive insights without friction or hidden fees. Ask whether the data can live in your preferred environment and whether the infrastructure can evolve with your needs.
- Ground the graph in the real world
Identity graphs should start with a known, verified offline record. That doesn’t mean you always need PII to succeed, but anchoring your graph in real-world data creates a stable foundation for scaling based on your own extensibility and privacy needs while reducing waste.
- Sense-check the numbers
Apply critical thinking. Does a data set claim more new movers than the number of people who actually relocate each year? Does a PII spine contain more records than the US population?
Your identity partner should be able to pass basic sniff tests. If results seem too good to be true, they probably are.
- Avoid lock-in; find a true partner
In a high-growth environment, you need more than customer service. You need a collaborator who helps you solve complex problems, test new strategies and move faster. If your partner isn’t bringing ideas to the table, they’re not keeping pace with your ambitions.
Choose partners that push you forward
The right identity and data infrastructure doesn’t just support your marketing goals; it accelerates them. Ensure your partner isn’t only along for the ride but actively helps you lead the way by becoming an integral part of that infrastructure and bringing insight and expertise to your process.
The future of addressable marketing belongs to those bold enough to demand better. Choose a partner that builds momentum, not drag.
For more articles featuring Paul Turner, click here.
